Oyster Pie (Casserole)

This is a recipe that my grandmother used for Thanksgiving and Christmas. Grandma modified hers a little, so I have shared both the original and the modified recipe. Enjoy!

Original Version:

1qt fresh oysters
12 saltines (crumbled)
4 eggs beaten
¼ cup cream
1/8 lb butter melted
Black pepper

Mix together in a casserole and bake at 350 degrees in a preheated oven for 30 minutes.

Grandma's Modified Version:

2- 8 or 12 oz fresh frozen containers Oysters
1 to 2 sleeves crushed saltines
4 eggs beaten
¼ cup can milk
1 stick butter
salt and pepper to tasted
1 can cream mushroom or chicken
½ cup chopped onion

Crush saltines and layer the bottom of casserole dish with one sleeve. Save the other sleeve for the top. Rinse and drain oysters then spread evenly on top of the saltines. Mix together milk, melted butter, eggs and cream of mushroom/chicken, beating until well blended. Sprinkle on top of oysters, leaving a little to pour over the top. Evenly distribute chopped onions and add salt and pepper if desired. Top with remaining saltines. Pour over remaining milk/butter/egg/soup mixture. Add pepper to top. Bake 350 degrees for 45 minutes to 1 hour.